The Institution for Science Advancement
  • Home
  • Start Here
  • Publications
    • Articles
    • Socratic Series
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • The Team
    • IFSA Advisory Council
    • Contact Us
  • Join Us
  • Support Us

Klein Bottle: Pouring Into Alien Geometries

7/1/2017

 
Picture
Remember when we used to dabble with alien geometries? IFSA is going back to our roots (which was planted in our first article about our logo), and this time we're tackling a cousin of that nefarious Mobius strip...
A mathematician named Klein,
Thought the Möbius band was divine.
Said he: "If you glue
The edges of two,
You'll get a weird bottle like mine."
​Leo Moser (1921 - 1970)
​If you like a drink, then a Klein bottle is not a recommended receptacle. It may look vaguely like a bottle, but it doesn't enclose any volume, which means that it can't actually hold any liquid. Whatever you pour "in" will just come back out again.
 
How do you construct such a strange thing and why would you want to construct it? The mathematician Felix Klein (1949 - 1925), who discovered the bottle in 1882, described it as a surface that "can be visualised by inverting a piece of a rubber tube and letting it pass through itself so that outside and inside meet".
 
It's obvious that the Klein bottle, just like the more familiar sphere, is a closed surface: it's finite in the sense that you can fit it into a finite region of space, but an ant could walk around on it forever without ever encountering a boundary or falling over an edge.

​Unlike the sphere, which has an inside and an outside, the Klein bottle is one-sided: walking around, our ant could reach both sides of each point of the surface. This is why the bottle encloses no volume, and it also answers the "why" question: the Klein bottle is interesting because we don't encounter many one-sided shapes in nature.
Picture
Picture
If this is a bit confusing, think of a simpler example of a one-sided surface: the famous Möbius strip. You can make one by taking two ends of a strip of paper, giving the strip a twist, and then gluing the ends together. By using a strip of paper whose two sides have different colours, say green and orange, it's easy to convince yourself that the resulting Möbius strip is one-sided. Once you have twisted and glued, you'll find that you can reach every orange point from every green point without having to pierce through the paper or climbing over its edge.
 
Unlike the Klein bottle, the Möbius strip does have a boundary — it is made up of the two non-glued edges of the original strip. But there is a link between the two. If you take two Möbius strips and create a closed shape by joining their boundaries using an ordinary two-sided strip, as shown below, what you get is exactly the Klein bottle.
Another curious feature of the Klein bottle is that it intersects itself, which means it's hard to make it from a single tube of rubber as Klein suggested (left). Strictly speaking, the self-intersecting object depicted above isn't a Klein bottle, but (as Klein indicated) only a visualisation of one. To understand why, first think of the more familiar doughnut (known mathematically as a torus). You can make a torus from a square sheet of rubber by first gluing two opposite sides to form a cylinder, and then gluing the two boundary components of that cylinder to get the torus.
 
If you don't want to bother with the gluing, you can simply think of the torus as a square, keeping in mind that opposite points on opposite sides are considered the same. So when you slide a shape drawn on the "square" across the top edge, it will re-appear at the bottom edge and when you slide it over the right edge it will re-appear at the left edge (and vice versa).
To get a true Klein bottle, start in the same way, identifying opposite points on a pair of opposite sides of a square. For the other pair of sides, however, don't identify points that are directly opposite, but points that are diagonally opposite, as shown in the picture.
 
The resulting object is the Klein bottle. Again, you can think of it as a square, keeping in mind which boundary points are considered the same. If you slide a shape over one of the edges that had opposite points identified (vertical in our picture), it reappears reappear on the opposite side, like before. If, however, you slide it over one of the edges whose points were identified diagonally (horizontal in our picture), it appears on the opposite side, but displaced and as a mirror image of its original self.
 
The only way to build this shape in three-dimensional space by actually gluing points together is to allow it to intersect itself. This amounts to identifying pairs of points in the interior of the original square, so strictly speaking the resulting shape is not exactly the same as the Klein bottle, which only has boundary points identified. It's just one way of representing the bottle in three-dimensional space (there are others too).
 
Curiously, the concepts of "inside", "outside" and "one-sidedness" depend on the ambient space an object is sitting in. For example, a loop drawn on a piece of paper (in two-dimensional space) has a well defined inside and outside, but a loop drawn in three-dimensional space doesn't. This is why we can't talk about one-sidedness unless we first decide how to embed a surface in three-dimensional space. There is, however, a closely related property that is intrinsic to a shape and doesn't depend on the surrounding space. A surface is called orientable if you cannot slide a shape drawn on it around and back to where it started so that it looks like its own mirror image. To give it its full mathematical description, the Klein bottle is a closed, non-orientable surface.
  Ponder this

A Mobius strip is a 2D plane shaped into a 3D object, but what about the Klein bottle? Is the intersected neck of the bottle 3D or 2D?

It's easy to imagine a normal bottle inside of another larger bottle, but is it possible to have a Klein bottle inside another Klein bottle?
  Discuss

Much of pure mathematics is abstract, as we had mentioned before, But are there any direct or indirect applications to the principles that describes the Klein bottle? Explore the concepts involved such as non-Euclidean geometry, and geometric topology, and relate them to applications in the real world.
  Further readings

Felix Klein, a German mathematician and mathematics educator, known for his work in group theory, complex analysis, and non-Euclidean geometry.

Klein bottle, our topic of the day.

Acme Klein Bottle, a company that constructs and sell mostly accurate Klein bottles, a good addition to the school lab.
      Topics


  About us

​Our Story
The Team
IFSA Advisory Council
  Join us

​Interested in expanding the minds of future Malaysian thinkers?
Join Us
  Support us

​It takes quite alot to teach, and much more to inspire.
Support Us
  Contact us

​Want to get in touch with us?
​

Contact Us
Picture
The Institution for Science Advancement is a non-profit organisation that promotes inquiry-based science education in Malaysian schools based on the principles of truth, liberty and merit.
​
The Institution for Science Advancement Ⓒ 2019
Sponsored by
Picture
  • Home
  • Start Here
  • Publications
    • Articles
    • Socratic Series
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • The Team
    • IFSA Advisory Council
    • Contact Us
  • Join Us
  • Support Us